The Jersey City File 098

Jersey City: The Man in the Doorway

Mary Robinson kept seeing a stranger outside her building. Two colleagues drove over to see for themselves, and one brought back a photograph.

Conceptual illustration (AI-generated) by The Unexplained

Jim Moseley handed the camera across the car. Timothy Green Beckley leaned towards the open window. There, in a doorway on a Jersey City street, stood the man Mary Robinson had been telling them about.

Beckley remembered a dark coat and a hat pulled low. He took one photograph of the man and another of a dark car at the curb. It was morning and there was traffic behind them. If they wanted to stop and talk to the stranger, they would have to go around the block.

The man Mary kept seeing

The way Beckley later told it, Mary noticed the man during the part of the morning when Jack had left for work and she would go out to shop. The stranger stood in a doorway near their apartment building. What drew her attention was that he seemed to be watching the people who came and went. When she saw him again, there was still no name to put to the figure in the hat.

John J. Robinson, known as Jack, was an assistant editor of Saucer News. Mary was an associate editor. In the spring issue, publisher Gray Barker ran a picture of Jack selecting a book from his research library. By summer, Moseley was listed as editor and Beckley as eastern editor. Mary knew both men through the magazine, and when she called, she was asking them to look into something happening outside her own home. Their colleagues heard about more than a man standing in the street. Beckley recalled that the Robinsons reported strange calls and that Jack’s UFO files appeared to have been disturbed. In his 2010 interview, Beckley described calls in which the person on the other end simply breathed into the phone.

The stranger outside was something Mary could describe and tell her colleagues where to look for. According to Beckley, she called more than once. He and Moseley wondered if she might be playing a joke or reading too much into a man on the street. They decided to drive over from Manhattan one morning without telling either of the Robinsons they were coming.

Around the block

Moseley was driving. Beckley, in the passenger seat, looked towards the doorway Mary had described. He remembered seeing someone dressed much as she had said, standing back from the street. A black car was parked near him. From inside Moseley’s car, Beckley could see them both.

In one account published in 2010, Beckley remembered narrow streets and rush-hour traffic. There was no easy place to pull up. Before they moved on, Moseley passed him the camera. Beckley put it out of the window long enough to take the two shots. There was still a chance to ask the man why he was there. They would find somewhere to park and go back to the doorway.

Beckley estimated that it took them five minutes to make the circuit. When they came back, the man was gone. So was the car at the curb. Beckley thought the stranger might have noticed the camera. He had no conversation to remember and no name to put beside the photograph.

Two pictures

The doorway photograph circulated with the story Beckley told. In the published reproduction a dark figure stands back from the pavement, his face hard to make out. The second image shows the rear of a dark car. It is possible to look from one picture to the other and see the two things that caught Beckley’s attention on that pass down the street. The man and the car never appear together in either frame.

Beckley kept telling the story as an encounter with a Man in Black. Moseley, who had driven the same block and handed him the camera, later wondered whether the man was a lookout for some unrelated business. The friends agreed there had been someone in the doorway. The part they had gone back to find out was the part they would tell differently.

What Is Known

The summer 1968 Saucer News masthead lists Mary and John J. Robinson, Moseley and Beckley on the staff. The encounter is generally dated to 1968. The sequence of the drive and the photographs comes from Beckley’s later recollections, and the published reproductions show a figure and a car in separate frames. The man’s identity and any connection to the Robinsons remain unknown.

The Bigger Picture

The same summer issue printed a reader’s letter about unsettling calls and a stranger in dark clothes. Readers of the magazine already had a name for that kind of visitor. In Jersey City the name stuck to a photograph taken in a few seconds from a passing car. The question Beckley wanted to ask had to wait until they got back around the block.

Sources